Vintage Tastings

By John Kapon

Experience the finest and rarest wines in the world through the eyes and palate of Acker Chairman and globally renowned master taster, John Kapon (our “JK”). “Vintage Tastings” is a written journal chronicling the incredible bottles opened at some of the most exclusive tastings, wine dinners, and events all over the globe. These entries represent JK’s commitment to capturing and sharing the ephemeral nature and ultimate privilege of tasting the world’s rarest wines. Although ratings are based on a 100-point scale, JK believes there is no such thing as a 100-point wine. Point scores assigned to each wine are his own personal attempt to quantify the quality of each experience.

Traveling Man

Lord, I was born a traveling man. I know those aren’t exactly the lyrics, but give me some creative courtesy please, because recently six weeks have seen me all over the world and then some. I’m still not sure if I am coming or going, but if I had to choose, I would always take coming.

This article will be a summation of six weeks in my life, which is about the last time I wrote an article. I will not get as in depth with every wine accordingly. There have been so many incredible wines and places over these six plus weeks, I don’t know where to begin. Then it became clear: just recap it all and let history be recorded. Then it became even clearer, and I had to paraphrase from the extremely talented and gifted Michael Madrigale, wine director of some of the Boulud Empire, hence assigning only three words per wine; otherwise, I would never get through this epic article. I’m getting older, I know.

Rare Selfie

Everything always starts in New York City. I know I am biased in regards to the hometown where I have lived 42 straight years, but it really is the genesis of many people, places and things. And when it comes to wine, there still isn’t a city that throws down as hard as NYC. There may be people in other cities that drink as well, and as often, but the collective wine drinking energy in NYC is second to none.

There was a celebration at Costata of Two Cellars that we sold a month or so ago, and it went a little something like this, hit it:

2004 Fleurot-Larose Montrachet Corked, 1er Cru, eh(DQ)
2004 Blain-Gagnard Montrachet Spice, anise, smooth(92)
2004 Drouhin Montrachet Marquis de Laguiche Sweet, polish, ice(95)
2004 Lafon Montrachet Cream, butter, sex(93)
2001 Roumier Bonnes Mares Dark, forest, unyielding(94)
2001 Vogue Musigny Milk, yeast, twang(93)
2001 Mugnier Musigny Purple, layers, heavy(95)
2001 Rousseau Chambertin Open, clean, great (96)
2007 DRC La Tache Green bean, saucy, garden(93)
2003 DRC La Tache Ripe, gamey, garden again(94)
1996 DRC La Tache Salami, rose, cocaine (96)

A Tale of Two Cellars

The wine of the night was the 1996 DRC La Tache. 1996 is a controversial vintage, not adored by all Burgundy lovers. Too much acid, not enough fruit, that’s the knock. The great ones are just starting to blossom, however, and this LT was a perfect example. It was ‘almost open,’ I wrote, fragrant with its bacon, garden, ham, salami and other assorted deli meats. Rose oil dripped in and out of this long and great wine. ‘Cocaine’ actually came from the crowd, but I’ll take credit (96).

There was a Volnay and a Leroy flight, but I was too busy making the rounds and didn’t take notes, and then there was a 1999 flight at Charlie Bird after the fact, featuring Rousseau, Mugnier, Angerville and others. I can’t exactly remember, so I must be coming up short. The next night I was off to Brazil. Yes, Brazil, that country hosting the World Cup and the Olympics, the B in BRIC, an amazing world just starting to awaken on a global level. It was an exciting and blurry week full of old and new friends, amazing places and great wines. It left me yearning more for this great country.

Feeling Special

I arrived in the AM, and lunch taught me immediately that the B in Brazil starts with Bordeaux:

1982 Lynch Bages Beef, classic, smooth (94)

2004 Margaux Wood, cassis, time(93)

Dinner was at one of the most magnificent homes I have ever seen, and we had a few very big bottles, most notably one out of Imperial:

2005 Valandraud Tasty, red fruits, drinkable(93I)

I choppered outside of Sao Paulo to a gorgeous country home with its own private zoo, but we drank like gentlemen, including:

1962 Cheval Blanc Lush, winter, carnivorous(95)

1989 La Mission Haut Brion Oceanic, black, wealthy(97+)

1995 Pegau Chat du Pape Cuvee Reserve 9L Strawberry, silk, soft(92S)

I went to the capital city, my first trip to Brasilia. We did a blind dance featuring myself and Brazil’s top sommelier, along with the US Ambassador, and we all drank together, some more than others:

1990 Lafite Rothschild Cedar, cassis, olive(95)

2001 Sena Catbox, coffee, tang (90)

2003 Margaux Sexy, chocolate, pine(95+)

2001 Ausone Game, acidity, bosom(95+)

2005 Sassicaia Fruity, different, Zinfandel(89)

2003 Cheval Blanc Rhone, lighter, disappointing(88)

2000 Barca Velha Sweet, seeds, Americano(91)

We also raided the cellar for some DRC and Leroy amongst others, but it was crowded in there, so no additional notes, sorry. My favorite wine of this lunch was the 2003 Margaux, although I will admit the crowd favored Lafite by 3 to 1! Manuel noted in the Margaux, ‘tobacco and coffee.’ The plus in my rating was for deliciousness as opposed to potential, as the ’03 Margaux was spilling out of its shirt. It was very forward, with the full sex appeal of 2003 on display. Hints of garden, chocolate and pine set the stage for a wine with intense character. This was not another floozy from 2003, as many want everyone to believe. There was excellent acidity in this rock star wine (95+).

I know, a full tasting note is better, forgive me for not writing them all.

Then I went to Rio for lunch.

2002 Margaux Tobacco, black, water(89M)

1997 Margaux Expressive, delicious, chocolate(93M)

1990 Margaux High, diamonds, amazing(96+)

1970 Cheval Blanc Menthol, complex, gorgeous(93M)

1975 Vieux Chateau Certan Plums, cobwebs, apricots(93)

1970 Petrus Plums, cinnamon, chocolate(97)

1976 Mouton Rothschild Caramel, honey, creamy (93)

1976 Ausone Red fruits, warm winter, stew(93)

1976 Ausone Red fruits, warm winter, stew(93)

If I wrote up the best wine of this meal, it would be the 1990 Margaux or the 1970 Petrus, but delicious trio of the 1997 Margaux and those two ’76s had me thinking more. Wines like those can exceed expectations; the great ones can only meet them. However, given that I don’t want this article to take an additional month to write, let’s talk about the 1970 Petrus. I have written up this wine many times, and this was a superb bottle. Chocolate and plums were in perfect harmony, and this wine’s sweetness and thickness were both second to none. Spices like cinnamon abounded; this was a wine with a mature knowledge lacking in these other young bucks. Speaking of bucks, the ’70 Petrus is still quite reasonable compared to other Petrus young bucks (97).

I also had dinner, resulting in 1970 Cheval Blanc twice in a day out of two formats.

1970 Cheval Blanc Same, warm, inviting(93)

1950 Lafite Rothschild VA, egg white, creepy(92)

1989 La Mission Haut Brion Midnight, chocolate, full(97+)

1989 Ausone Milk, dust, yeasty (91)

My last night in Rio saw me with The Shocker. He is much better in Rio 2 than in Spider Man 2. We ended with a trio of 98 and 99 point Cali Cabernets.

2000 Krug Clos du Mesnil Thick, citrus, grit(95)

1990 Chapoutier Ermitage Le Pavillon Mint, violet, ham(95)

1995 Margaux Tobacco, cassis, silk(95+)

2007 Maybach Materium Vanilla, booberry, juice(90)

2007 Spottswoode Cabernet Caramel, same, same(90)

2007 Continuum Same, same, same? (90)

It was very difficult for me to differentiate amongst these young, sweet Calis. Perhaps my palate needs more time to appreciate them as much as others, but it was a Margaux kind of week for me, basically a mini-vertical over the course of a few days. The 1995 Margaux was very open and forward, pleasing with its coffee, tobacco, cassis and black forest aromas and flavors. Its palate was soft and silky (95+).

I headed south, close to the border to meet El Gordo for the biggest dinner of them all. I know, he sounds like a drug dealer, but he is actually one of Brazil’s most enthusiastic wine lovers, even if he sells by the ounce and pound lol.

1. 1985 Krug Orangesicle, vanilla, zip (95+)
2. 1992 Ramonet Montrachet Corn, kink, peacock (98)
3. 1988 DRC La Tache Weeds, black rose, yeast blossom (94)
4. 1966 Latour Walnut, cassis, harmony (96)
5. 1945 Calon Segur Chanel box, leather, monster (97)
6. 1961 Haut Brion Cooked (DQ)
7. 1961 Lafleur Cooked (DQ)
8. 1959 Latour Classic, fresh, deep ocean (97)
9. 1928 Latour Bandaid, thick, chalky (95)
10. 1961 Ducru Beaucaillou Garden, green, tobacco (93)
11. 1928 Suduiraut Mahogany, honey, bikini wax (94)

La La La

This evening was extraordinary, enough so that I can’t just give one wine all the credit. As far as white wines go, it doesn’t get much better than the 1992 Ramonet Montrachet. Its amazing nose was sweet, nutty and fruity, with tree bark, corn, kink and rainwater aromas. It was incredibly complex and concentrated. I could taste it a minute later, and the drop of banana on its finish blended well into its peacock tail of acidity. This was a spectacular wine, possessing unreal greatness and transcending the vintage. Caramel coated the glass as my last sip became an everlasting memory (98) .

Let’s also talk about the 1945 Calon Segur. In my humble opinion, 1945 is the greatest vintage of all-time; well, at least the 20th Century. It is stunningly great everywhere, and this Calon was no exception. Cedar, meat and new Chanel box dripped out of the nose, and its rustic edge gave a little pepperoni appeal. ‘Horse sweat’ and ‘aged leather’ came from the crowd, and there was great acidity and pinpoint balance to this stunning wine. This was a beautiful, and delicious, monster (97).

Wine of the Vintage

The 1959 Latour was not surprisingly great. There was gorgeous fruit to this fresh bottle. Walnut, cassis, minerals and cedar performed together like a great quartet. This was ‘deep ocean,’ and its thick and long finish still came across elegantly (97).

I went to Hong Kong, even though there wasn’t an auction, but I lost my notes. I hate it when that happens. There was a bit of a Burgundy Paulee, and over 30 wines were tasted, the best of which was a stunningly delicious 1991 Dujac Clos de la Roche (97).Dagnabbit!

Literally the next day I was back in NYC at about 130pm, and by 430pm I was with Antonio Galloni, arriving at Del Posto for Tuscany in the City, although we drank more than Tuscany had to offer. Bad Boy, The Punisher, The Rev, The Hedonist and even Restaurant Joe showed up, and the pre-party was almost as good as the post-party. Suffice it to say, the legend of Bad Boy grew by about two times thanks to The Ice Princess and The Bad Ass Bitch. They chose their own names by the way. Soldera was the wine of the night, and per The Ice Princess, ‘it slid down the throat as smoothly as…’ Shit, I can’t read my writing again…seriously…

Pictures Help Memory

The Pre-Tasting:
1. 1986 Ramonet Bienveues Batard Lush, zippy, atypical (95)
2. 1976 Philipponat Clos Goisses Wheaty, rusty, orange (93M)
3. 1961 Krug Collection Vanilla, earth, imperfect (94A)
4. 1996 Leflaive Bienveues Batard Corndust, long, mineral (95)
5. 1996 Niellon Chevalier Mature, honeydew, caramel (93)
6. 1978 DRC Richebourg Complete, powerful, epiphany (97)
7. 1982 Krug Clos du Mesnil Tight, might, lift (97)
8. 1990 Tignanello Sauce, spice, grandma (94)
9. 1989 Leroy Latricieres Chambertin Gas, grain, exotic (94+)
10. 1900 Lafite Rothschild Tender, tertiary, creamy (93)
11. 1976 Salon White fruit, easy, delicious (95M)
12. 1961 Moet RD Grass, wheat, vim (91M)
The Main Event:
1. 1982 Soldera Deep, beast, perfect (97)
2. 1985 Soldera Funky, corked, stewed (DQ)
3. 1986 Soldera Tasty, nutty, outstanding (95)
4. 1987 Soldera Darker, blacker, disgruntled (93)
5. 1988 Soldera Dense, leathery, spicy (96)
6. 1993 Soldera Buttery, honeyed, beany (93)
7. 2001 Felsina Chianti Riserva Rancia Yolk, dry, tasty (92)
8. 2002 Bollinger Vieilles Vignes Fr. Baked, gamey, exotic (94)
9. 1980 Solaia Greenbean, smooth, goodness (90)
10. 2002 Jacques Selosses Verve, rich, bready (95)
11. 1982 Pol Roger Winston Churchill Vitamins, cream, full (94)
12. 1961 Ducru Beaucaillou Soft, green pepper, plush (93)
13. 1994 Masseto Milky, cola, round (93)
14. 1995 Soldera Rich, buttery, luscious (93)
15. 1989 DRC Montrachet Weedy, thorny, awkward (92)
16. 2001 DRC Montrachet Creamy, smoky, delicious (95)
17. 1985 DRC Richebourg Autumnal, dirty, rose hips (94M)
18. 1999 Soldera Solid, big, classic (94)
19. 2000 Soldera Redder, lush, smack (93)
20. 2001 Soldera Soft, smooth, disappointing (91)
21. 1990 Soldera Meat, materials, longest (97+)

This evening was really about Soldera. As good as the 1978 DRC Richebourg and 1982 Krug Clos du Mesnil were, I will write first about the 1982 Soldera. This was a rare beast, and a good descriptor. Fresh, shy yet deep, this was a perfect bottle of aged Soldera, and its palate revealed red cherry, leather and that Soldera twang that makes it so unique. Fleshy and chewy, it left a vivid imprint on my palate and on my mind (97).

While the 1985 was off, the 1986 was another stunner, definitely in the outstanding category with its tasty, nutty character. The 1987 was deeper, darker and bigger, but its personality didn’t exude as much pleasure as the 1986. 1988 was another outstanding example, ‘rocking’ and consistent with its dusty, spicy, leathery and sandpapery qualities. There was great acidity in this ‘different experience.’ The 1993 was another theoretically lesser year that delivered above its weight class. It was rich and buttery, honeyed and delicious with signature profiles. ‘Burnt beans’ added to the usual twang. 1995 added egg yolks to the usual mix, arguably part of the usual twang. The 1999 was also solid, while the 2000 was one of the redder fruit wines of the family.

Tuscany’s Greatest Wine

The 2001 was the only disappointing one, and the 2004 was just too young and too sweet at this point. The 1990 was a monster, a man amongst boys even by Soldera’s standards. It is arguably one of the greatest Italian wines made, ever. Got my Soldera paragraph in, I feel better now. That deserves its own article, but it is just one part of one night during this insane stretch, and about thirty notes are already missing!

I stayed in New York, and later that week we had another Acker Paulee, again in honor of the Tale of Two Cellars auction that would happen two days later. After thirty-two wines, I stumbled out of there in fine, Acker fashion.

1. 1990 Dom Perignon Rose Tight, vitamin, solid (94M)
2. 1979 Roederer Cristal Butterscotch, gold, dry (95)
3. 2000 Dujac Echezeaux Trees, stems, woodsy (92)
4. 2000 Drouhin Montrachet MdL Corn, long, delicious (95)
5. 1973 Dom Perignon Wheat, bittersweet, even-keeled (94)
6. 1969 Dom Perignon (RD) Mushroom, sweet, yellow (95)
7. 1975 Dom Perignon (RD) Grass, weeds, fresh (94+)
8. 1996 Dom Leflaive Batard Yellowstone, full, acid (96)
9. 1996 Dom Leflaive Chevalier Closed, minerals, potential (95+)
10. 1983 Dom Leflaive Chevalier Rainwater, sweet, stones (93M)
11. 2001 Dom Leflaive Batard Ripe, tender, one-dimension (93)
12. 1995 Bouchard Chevalier Mature, caramel, drinkable (92)
13. 1993 Leroy Vosne Beauxmonts Deep, black, signature (95)
14. 1991 Leroy Vosne Beauxmonts Corked (DQ)
15. 1990 Leroy Vosne Beauxmonts Fatter, sandy, gritty (92)
16. 1998 Dujac Clos de la Roche Delicate, purple, long (93M)
17. 1990 Rouget Vosne Cros P Green, goodness, thickens (95)
18. 1990 Rouget Echezeaux Weighty, black, smooth (93)
19. 1995 Dujac Clos de la Roche Hard, full, solid (93M)
20. 1980 Jacqueline Jayer Echezeaux Animal, wild, funky(93)
21. 1991 DRC Grands Echezeaux Ready, delicious, DRC (95)
22. 1990 DRC Grands Echezeaux Thicker, complex, equal (95)
23. 1990 DRC Romanee St. Vivant Slutty, smoother, spice (95)
24. 1991 DRC Romanee St. Vivant Extravagant, sexy, spin (95)
25. 1985 DRC Richebourg Delicious, spectacular, wow (97)
26. 1990 Dujac Clos de la Roche Everlasting, core, purple (97)

There was more, but I can’t remember it all. There was a disappointing Roumier Bonnes Mares flight at the end with some big-time vintages, but I will chalk that up to palate fatigue, although La Machina had the same observation. Theory number two is that the two last wines not only exceeded everything before them, but possibly destroyed everything thereafter as well. They were superlative, spectacular wines, but by that point, my writing wasn’t so much so.

Next thing I know I was in LA, where Uncle Matty was hosting a Royal Order of Purple Palate dinner with Bipin, Hollywood Jef, The Good Doctor, Say It Ain’t Joe and the rest of the gang. Down at the Bar of Republique, I had by the glass:

Ah, Malibu

1. 1981 Vega Sicilia Unico Leather, cream, semi (94)
2. 2002 Cristal Too young but gets credit, not 3 words (92)
3. 1999 Marcassin Ch Marcassin Vyd Rhonish, kinky, SQN? (93)
4. 1992 Lafon Meursault Charmes Elegant, wax, honey (94)
5. 2007 Lafon Meursault Charmes Round, tasty, simpler(93)
6. 1978 Camille Giroud Corton Oatmeal, dusty, interesting (93)
7. 1978 Gaja Sori San Lorenzo Tar, desert, sweet (94)
8. 1978 Chalone Pinot Noir Menthol, candy, complicated (94)
9. 1971 Ridge Cabernet Stinky, tangy, off (DQ)
10. 1971 Ridge Cab Eisele Vyd Asphalt, chocolate, earth (96)
11. 1971 Ridge Cab Monte Bello Same earth, cassis, ripe (93)

Whites of Different Feathers

There was another flight, but it was off the record…the 1971 Ridge Cabernet Eisele Vineyard had that good, old-fashioned, California Cabernet nose. There were lots of cedar and asphalt aromas, with leather, earth and chocolate flavors supporting its ripe palate. There was a drop of honey to this open and sexy red (95).

A First Growth From California

The next day I was at Spago for lunch, a lunch of Lafleur and Petrus, organized by the Godfather, but influenced by The Catalyst and The Bordeauxinator. It was good to see Bordeaux being opened in the USA, and even better that it was two of the Right Bank’s biggest names.

1. 1985 Lafleur Mint, apricot, cranberry (93)
2. 1989 Lafleur Brooding, deeper, wound (97)
3. 1993 Petrus Plum, olive, underrated (93)
4. 1990 Lafleur Effusive, cherry bomb, jam (95)
5. 2000 Lafleur Regal, saucy, fantastic (98)
6. 1970 Petrus Flamboyant, coconut, mocha (95A)
7. 1975 Petrus Fresh, cherry, perfect (96)
8. 1982 Petrus Velvet, citrus, olive (97)

Petrus and Lafleur always make for an excellent debate, and as impressive as the ’82 Petrus was, as great as the ’89 Lafleur (usually) was, and as delicious as the ’75 Petrus (usually) was, the 2000 Lafleur stole the show. Talk about benchmark. This was a monstrous wine that was surprisingly accessible, with loads of fruit. When I say accessible, it’s kind of like Mount Everest being accessible. There was still a long road ahead for this wine to develop and unfurl. Rich, saucy, plum fruit came across regally, and its thick finish was fantastic. This was Pomerol at its finest (98).

I went straight to a massage, and then straight to dinner at SLS. There were numerous, fabulous people, most notably Hollywood Jef and The Rev, although there were more recognizable people in the restaurant and at our table.

1. 1996 Krug Classic, 96, always (95)
2. 1989 Krug Clos du Mesnil Big, honey, royalty (97+)
3. 2006 Dom Leflaive Batard Sweet, yellow, lush (94)
4. 2001 Dom Leflaive Chevalier Botrytis, stone, fine (93)
5. 1985 Drouhin Chevalier Shellfish, horsesweat, weird (88A)
6. 2001 Clos des Papes Floral, dominatrix, kink (92)
7. 1928 Paternina Rioja G Reserva Caramel, smooth, dust (92)
8. 1954 Lopez de Heredia Bosconia Beautiful, tasty, long (92)
9. 1986 Pesquera Janus Catbox, smoke, red fruit (90)
10. 1991 Pesquera Janus Old closet, thick, peculiar (92)
11. 1994 Pesquera Janus Great, yeast, progression (94)
12. 1970 Vega Sicilia Unico Creamy sex, leather, delicious (97)
13. 1962 La Mission Haut Brion Gravel, dark, improves (93)
14. 1982 Pichon Lalande Silky, peanut, tasty (95)
15. 1986 Margaux Squirrel, ammonia, eh (DQ)
16. 1985 Mascarello Barolo Smooth, tar, leather (94)
17. 2003 Pegau Chateauneuf Capo Booberry, crack, juice (93)

More Of That Good Stuff

I didn’t get much time to take an in-depth note of the Krug, but I did for the 1970 Vega Sicilia Unico, which was still very young despite being 44! The Rev commented that it was ‘not as exotic and as open as other vintages,’ and 1981, 1973 and 1962 were mentioned. However, that was not to detract from the 1970, which was deep, earthy, leathery and creamy. Vanilla sex was the flavor that summed up its awesomeness (97).

I think that was it. I got a couple of Hollywood hugs, although I haven’t had as many Hollywood laughs since hanging with Hollywood Jef for 48 hours. He is one of the most comedic geniuses ever, and I love comedy. By the time I sobered up, I was in Burgundy. The Mogul and I had a date, and the women were in tow.

Burgundy

I ran into many people unexpectedly, most notably The Punisher. I tasted a lot of wines, went to Lameloise, but I wrote up only one event. We had a party, celebrating Etienne de Montille’s birthday, and numerous Domaines were well represented in person and in the bottle.

What 3 Stars Looks Like in Burgundy

1. 2011 De Montille Puligny Caillerets Honeysuckle, sauce, cream (93)
2. 2007 Delarche Corton Charlemagne Sweet, minerals, driven (94)
3. 2007 Bonneau du Martray Corton Charlemagne Ripe, honey, dry (92)
4. 2006 Drouhin Montrachet Laguiche Heavy, botrytis, endless (95)
5. 2004 Drouhin Clos des Mounes Blanc Grass, rainwater, sweet (92)
6. 1979 Ch de la Tour Clos Vougeot Souis bois, raspberry, twisted (94M)
7. 1961 Engel Vosne Romanee 1erCru Orange, anise, tobacco (93)
8. 1941 Moignon Amoureuses VA, teriyaki, nectar (93A)
9. 1988 Leroy NSG Boudots Kick, musk, rust, pretty (93)
10. 1989 Meo-Camuzet Clos Vougeot Gamey, buttery, square (93)
11. 1990 Engel Clos Vougeot Celery soda, strawberries, fresh herbs (94)
12. 1980 DRC Romanee St. Vivant Classic, menthol, iron (96)
13. 2000 Chandon des Briailles Pernand V. Solid, bright, character (90)
14. 1994 Chave Hermitage mag Roasted, mint, provencal (94M)
15. 1974 Ridge Monte Bello Cedar, ocean, supple (94)
16. 1963 Taylor Happy, Birthday, Etienne (96)

The 1980 DRC Romanee St. Vivant was a classic DRC from an underrated vintage. It has a great nose full of menthol, iron, blood, mint and spice. This wine was the definition of sous bois in a delicious way, and its rich, saucy and spicy palate had great texture to do with its mature flavors. Hubba hubba (96).Speaking of sous bois, the 1979 Chateau de la Tour Clos Vougeot got an honorary mention for old, earthy goodness. Tobasco, ripe raspberry, cassis and wet fur all competed for my attention. There was this twisted citrus and earth combination, this just right touch of Worcestershire brown, and slaty fruit. It had the best of both old and young (94M).

The next best thing was a weekend in Nantucket, headlined by Gentleman Jim, Lady Agah, Semi-Wild Bill and Jenny P. We would not have been there were it not for Magic Mark, and his entourage, of course. The Nantucket Wine Festival is a great event to kick off summer, and I highly recommend you go next year and enjoy the Acker Merrall VIP experience.

Nantucket

On the first night, we did 1989. As in Bordeaux, beginning with:
1. 1989 Talbot Green bean, cassis, bite (90)
2. 1989 Leoville Barton Fuller, woodsy, square (91+)
3. 1989 Cos d’Estournel Paprika, purple, polished (93)
4. 1989 Montrose Shy yet voluptuous, black, fantastic (96)
5. 1989 Pontet Canet Dry, austere, tight (88)
6. 1989 Pichon Lalande Smooth, elegant, drinkable (93)
7. 1989 Lafite Rothschild Pencil, elegant, weight (94)
8. 1989 Lynch Bages Big, huge, brute (95+)
9. 1989 La Mission Haut Brion Chocolate, blueberry, toffee (97)
10. 1989 La Fleur Petrus Garden, tobacco, tight (93)
11. 1989 L’Evangile Wet, wheat, fleshy (93)
12. 1989 La Conseillante Caressing, plum, spicy (96)
13. 1989 Clinet Big, round, square (94)

This was my third 1989 La Mission Haut Brion of this article, so I guess I will finally pay official homage. Consistently great, the thing about the ’89 La Miss is its wealth of fruit. Black, blue and purple still often masquerade like a barrel sample in this youthful behemoth. Sweetness is at the core of this ‘chocolaty,’ ‘BBQ,’ ‘blueberry’ and toffee extravaganza. It is opulent, and certainly a 100-year wine, although I am still, and always have been, in the Haut Brion camp when it comes to these dueling legends (97).

The next day we tasted in the afternoon, as in 1999 Red Burgundies, blind to change things up. We took votes for first, second and third place, maybe fourth. Votes for first place would be four if four votes, three for second place, etc. Below is in order served:

1999 Red Burgundy

1. 1999 Faiveley Corton Clos des Cortons Nutty, rusty, leaner (88) 11th place, no votes
2. 1999 Groffier Bonnes Mares Pungent, animal, cerise (94) 2nd place, 28 votes
3. 1999 Jadot Chambertin Clos de Beze Austere, tight, black (92+) 8th place, 4 votes
4. 1999 Ponsot Clos de la Roche VV Mushroom, white pepper, ripe (93) 10th place, 2 votes
5. 1999 Roty Charmes Chambertin TVV Ample, complex, improves (95) 9th place, 3 votes
6. 1999 Drouhin Chambertin Serious acidity, flavorful, terroir (96+) 6th place, 13 votes
7. 1999 Vogue Bonnes Mares Plum, dark, vanilla (94) 7th place, 10 votes
8. 1999 Jadot Musigny ‘ White chocolate butter cream’, meat, long (96) 3rd place, 27 votes
9. 1999 Faiveley Mazis Chambertin Olive, citrus, lean n mean (93) 11th place, no votes
10. 1999 Roumier Bonnes Mares Sauvage, zip, flesh (94) 5th place, 15 votes
11. 1999 DRC Grands Echezeaux Jam, oaky, herbal (92) 4th place, 21 votes
12. 1999 Meo-Camuzet Clos Vougeot Thick, long, serious (96+) 1st place, 37 votes!

The Drouhin Chambertin (which is all Clos de Beze by the way) had serious, deep, black fruit. It had the best acidity of the day so far; some of the 1999s can lack a little due to the major fruit of the vintage. That’s the knock for those that want to detract from this great vintage, but there are more success stories than anything else, for sure. There was ‘a real sense of terroir,’ and a long, flavorful finish with kisses of citrus (96+).The 1999 Meo-Camuzet Clos Vougeot really stole the show at the end. This is definitely what I would call an upset; that’s the beauty of a blind tasting. There are always surprises on the positive and negative side. The Meo was seriously shy in its nose, but it was intriguing and deep. ‘Could be the best wine of the day,’ I wrote. Its thickness and length impressed me, and most others (96+).There’s a lot more to be said about this tasting, but we had to go grab lunch, watch the Preakness, and get ready for Nantucket’s version of La Paulee, or La Fete, as it has been crowned. We started with a couple whites before going deep into the red rabbit hole:

It’s A Party

1. 1999 Drouhin Montrachet Laguiche Full, flavorful, classic (95)
2. 1989 Trimbach Riesling Frederic Emile Peach, petrol, minerals (94)
3. 1985 Vogue Bonnes Mares Gamey, beefy, tea sauce (92)
4. 1978 Murrieta Rioja Ygay Riserva Vanilla, creamy, delicious (93)
5. 1994 Vega Sicilia Unico Egg cream, classy, young (95)
6. 1994 Sauzet Montrachet Rainwater, tropical, impressive (94)
7. 1980 Penfolds Grange Cherry bomb, saucy, oy oy oy (93)
8. 1989 Mugnier Musigny VV Brothy, rich, shroom (93)
9. 1971 DRC La Tache Tomato, beef stew, amazing acid (97)
10. 1983 Haut Brion Gravel, carob, smooth (93)
11. 1999 Chapoutier Ermitage de L’Oree Glue, beeswax, viscosity (92)
12. 1987 DRC Grands Echezeaux Rusty, menthol, solid (93)
13. 1928 La Mission Haut Brion Library, tobacco road, chewy (94)
14. 1964 Pavie (Imperial) Stony, dark, excellent (93I)
15. 1970 Vieux Chateau Certan Pure, lean, classic (92)
16. 1982 Lafite Rothschild Satin, definition, refined (95)
17. 1945 Mouton Rothschild Deep, deeper, deepest (98)
18. 1955 Cantina Masarello Barolo Leather, tobacco, brown sugar (95M)
19. 1989 La Mission Haut Brion See yesterday’s notes (97+)
20. Wickedly good hallucinogenic Yellow Chartreuse (97+) Wickedly good hallucinogenic Yellow Chartreuse (97+)

Beauty & the Beast

It was a fast and furious evening, and I didn’t take my best notes, but it was nice to cap another legendary adventure with two legends like the 1971 DRC La Tache and the 1945 Mouton Rothschild. The La Tache was brothy and beefy with an amazing tomato stew and outstanding acidity, while the Mouton was just everything one could ask for in an older Bordeaux. Despite other legends like ’89 La Mission (again!) and 1982 Lafite, there was clearly one Bordeaux a head and shoulders above the rest.

The most unique experience of the trip was my last, an authentic, French, old school Chartreuse outlawed in the US due to the use of wormwood, which apparently gives off some hallucinogenic action. These can only legally be acquired in France, and there is one book that has all the recipes for the different batches, which are blends of different vintages, and the one we had was from the mid-sixties. This was the after-dinner drink to end all after-dinners. This was like a Mayweather knockout blow; I can’t believe I drank the whole thing. There wasn’t much gas left in the tank after that, and two auctions in two cities were approaching over the next two weeks. Time to do it all over again.

In Vino Veritas,
JK

Chicagoland Gang

About two weeks ago, I went to Chicago just for dinner, and it was well worth the trip. Being the “Capone” that I am often called by random people all over the world, I figured it would be nice to see some of the wine gang in town, so I called the X-Factor, and, as they say, it was done.

A magnum of 1990 Pol Roger Sir Winston Churchill welcomed me, still young out of magnum. It was bready and rusty with aromas of white fruits and minerals. The X-Factor was first to reveal his wine superpowers, commenting ‘very ’90, very ripe’ (95+M).

Two Leflaives followed, the first being a stellar 1999 Domaine Leflaive Chevalier Montrachet. It had a classic nose full of sweet yellow fruit, wet rain and rock. It was sweet and musky, ‘lush fat and sexy’ per the X-Factor. Its palate was also rocky with an edgy quality. Over time, more corn and sweetness came out, but this was first and foremost a muscly 1999, full and deliciously typical (95).

The 2002 Domaine Leflaive Chevalier Montrachet was unfortunately off (DQ).

We went deep on first and ten with a 1971 DRC Richebourg courtesy of the X-Factor. He was making his presence felt early and often. Ten years ago, this was his best wine ever, and it was still pretty damn close. Hulkamania found it ‘beefy,’ and there were also aromas of rose hips, vitamins, earth, saddle sweat and a touch of menthol. Hulkamania continued, hailing the ’71 ‘tasty bitches.’ There was some oceanic action in its nose, but I couldn’t quite identify how. The X-factor found it ‘mineral driven.’ Its palate was red and black cherry with a spicy, ‘wasabi’ like finish, observed the Earlycomer, who is always first to arrive. Its flavors had a kiss of brine, but its incredible acid had Magnum Man feeling like he was ‘driving a John Deere tractor.’

It was a very good year and mine

The Earlycomer then added that it was more like a ‘girl in sexy knickers on a tractor.’ He then proceeded to come all over himself lol. I’m still not sure if it was the girl or the Richebourg (96).

A 1971 Arnoux Romanee St.Vivant was reconditioned and not up for the challenge. It was metallic, almost like bad fish tank. It got better, moving in a bamboo and wet frog direction, if that can be a positive thing. It was soft and lush but still weedy and fuzzy (88).

There was an ‘intermezzo’ per The Earlycomer. He was back rather quickly, quite persistent. All attention was required for the 1990 Leroy Romanee St. Vivant. This was a big wine, fitting of the reputation that preceded its bringer, Mr. John Holmes. Yes, reports of his demise were premature, as there is a John Holmes alive and well in Chicago. Even Rollergirl wheeled on by later and pecked him on his cheek. Back to the Leroy, which had aromas of deep fruit and black forest, along with Gretel and all her friends. The Earlycomer noted ‘layers of glycerin and density’ and then proceeded to come all over himself again. There was a touch of cola and a little gas to this slick and thick red. It was full and fresh with black flavors, long like its owner (95).

Intermezzo

We went back to the older with a 1969 Faiveley Chambertin Clos de Beze. The Earlycomer was loving it and its earthy, wheaty and pop tart goodness. Its palate was meaty, rich, full and fleshy for a 1969. There was a tree bark to its palate in a solid way (93).

The 1976 Rousseau Chambertin Clos de Beze was menthol city, ‘square for Rousseau,’ someone noted. The X-Factor admired its concentration, especially given the vintage. Its palate was gritty with great spice, great acidity and great dryness. This was impressive for a 1976, which would make sense since Rousseau probably makes the best wines in the worst years, in addition to making the best wines in the best years. This was an open and sexy wine, flirting with 95 points with its weedy spice, hot rock and wheaty bushel (94).

Oldies and goodies

Unico! We had four vintages on tap between 1959 and 1965, and the glove fit except for John Holmes. We started with a superb 1959 Vega Sicilia Unico. Coffee, yogurt and mocha were all spilling out of its nose, soon joined thereafter by great gingerbread and gumdrop. This nose was beyond exotic, like a half Brazilian, half Chinese girl who went to college in London. This vintage was Burgundian in character, except for the so much coffee thing happening. There was a nice finish to this outstanding wine, which kept getting better. The Earlycomer noted ‘butterscotch candy.’ We all know what happened next (96).

Ay ay ay ay

The 1960 Unico that followed was blacker as in berries, shut down in the nose but solid in the mouth. It was a bit slatier and thicker than the ’59, but it had nice body, like asphalt without the sun. Its big finish was admired by all of the above (93).

There was only one place to go next, the 1961 Unico, of course. Its nose was coffee, chocolate and wheat, ‘more depth’ per the Hulkamania. It was long and balanced, also Burgundian like the 1959, with red cherry and leather flavors. It kept extending (96).

The 1965 Unico was a bit reduced and ‘muddy.’ Holmes found it ‘less precise’ than the other Unicos, and it was a bit floral and sour at the same time. It had a fleshy and leathery palate, better than its nose for sure (91).

There was one last flight to go, and Latour was up for the challenge. The 1953 Latour had a classic nose with walnut, mineral, spice and great cassis fruit. This was full-bodied for ’53, but its palate fell back into typical mode with a beautiful, long and smooth finish. There were nice tea leaf and slate flavors (93).

The 1955 Latour was like band-aid meets marijuana, with deep fruit supporting the whole operation. Its palate was long and full with sparkling black fruit. Sparkling as in shining, not that this was some sort of Latour Perignon lol. It kept getting better and stronger in the glass (95).

Magnum Man found the 1959 Latour to be a ‘big dark fruit explosion.’ It had a great nose with super spice and the most kink. There was a thickness yet a quickness to its palate, which was long, great and classic in every sense of the word (97).

La la la

Some more damage was done when we went back to the beautiful home cellar of The Earlycomer. We sampled numerous other wines, including 1997 Jadot Chapelle Chambertin (91), 1990 Drouhin Griotte Chambertin (94),and a pair of Italians, a 1982 Giacosa Barbaresco Santo Stefano Riserva (94) and a 1982 Gaja Sori Tilden (94).I couldn’t keep up with the notes, or the wines, as I think we had another three or four more down in the cellar. It was about that time that I lost track, but at least I didn’t lose my notes. I look forward to losing my way again for another night in the near future with my Chicagoland gang.

The saga continues

In Vino Veritas,
JK

Viva Italia

Antonio Galloni has become one of the more respected critics in the wine world today, and not surprisingly, his passion started with the wines of Italy. In a couple weeks on April 26th, he will be hosting ‘Tuscany in the City,’ and you can still sign up at vinousmedia.com if there are seats left. I will definitely be there. And I was there last year when he did the same event for Piedmont, and I have been saving this write up as long as I can remember. Since all things French tend to dominate both the market and my articles, this was an evening that I promised I would revisit before a year had passed, as so many rare vintage Italians were sampled. Sorry, no pictures this round.

Italian wines happen to be a passion of mine as well, and this incredible night started off in the fast lane with a 1978 Scavino Barolo Bric del Fiasc. Its nose was full of fireplace love along with spice box and rack aromas. Nutmeg, cinnamon and cigar box took center stage. Its palate was fantastic, rich and saucy with high acidity, zip and vigor. Flavors of rose, chocolate and tobacco graced all of our mouths, and there was no question this wine was still ascending. There was great smack to its ass (96).

Antonio was excited by the 1988 Vietti Barolo Rocche, and its deep nose showed more mint and chocolate. There was a touch of Ben Gay menthol in there, and its palate possessed pretty cranberry flavors with nice citrus tension. There was solid acidity in this excellent wine (93).

The 1990 Giuseppe Mascarello Barolo Monprivato was served out of magnum. Deep was a recurring theme, this time in thick fashion with black fruit, oil and sweet asphalt. There was a conflict between red and black cherry on the palate, but a touch of syrupy goodness resolved matters, along with great richness. It got a touch tangy (95M).

Giuseppe had to be outdone by another magnum, this one being a 1989 Bartolo Mascarello Barolo, which had a musky, sexy, slaty and dusty nose. It was smoky, seeping out of the glass in a shy way. Its palate was thick and spicy, classic in every which way of the word (96M).

The 1989 Giacosa Barbaresco Santo Stefano Riserva was at first lighter and more reticent than expected. By the way, I am sure I am not listing ‘Riserva’ for every wine appropriately, apologies in advance, most of the wines on this night were probably Riservas. There were aromas of smoke, leather and backside in a beautiful way. The palate was smooth and elegant, again more so than expected, but its smooth, satiny and stylish finish had me intoxicated. It kept expanding and flexing more and more, really benefitting from extra time in the glass. Its tannins were dry like a good desert (96).

The magnum of 1985 Bartolo Mascarello Barolo had smoky and deep black fruit with chunky and sweet tar and tobacco aromas, almost everything I could want in a Piedmont nose, including some hot asphalt. Its palate was more about the cherry, and it was softer and easier with pretty chalk and red citrus flavors. The Chairman found it too ‘cold,’ while Luca Vietti found it ‘Burgundian’ (93M).

We continued with the ’85 theme with a 1985 Sandrone Barolo Cannubi Boschis. Antonio found it ‘stellar’ and someone else ‘fresh.’ Again, there was this great nose full of oil, asphalt, chocolate and black fruit. It seeped hotness, but the palate was ‘dry and breaking up’ per Bobby. While it was dry for sure, it was a little hard not to like it (93).

A 1985 Rinaldi Barolo kept consistent with the other ’85s, despite showing its own unique personality. This was coffee city, sweeter with some stalk and stink, a bit wild but still excellent. Overall, the 1985 Piedmonts seem to be in a spot where I wouldn’t hesitate to drink (93).

An intermezzo of 1988 Salon was most welcome, and probably thanks to Bad Boy. It was a great bottle, the best of this that I can remember, full of oil and a sweet finish, still the white lightning of Champagne (96).

The 1978 Gaja Sori Tilden had browned sugar fruit with tobacco and nutty aromas along with oat and the meal. Its palate was creamy, medium-bodied in a nice way, with lots of leather and acid on its finish (94).

A 1971 Prunotto Barbaresco Rabaja magnum ‘tasted like French wine.’ It was smooth with light nut and lots of crevice qualities, ie smack and slate. This was a nice wine that was tasty and still fresh with good acid and a citrus backside (93M).

The 1990 Giacosa Barolo Collina Rionda Riserva had a deep, nutty nose that was almost celery soda. Its sweet black fruit moved me in an Italian cannoli direction, with a little Zamboni action. It was smoother than I expected (93).

The 1990 Giacosa Barbaresco Santo Stefano Riserva that followed also had a touch of that celery soda thing happening, but it was richer, longer and prouder than the Collina. There was a lot of zippedy doo dah to its nose, and great balance between its sweet earth, nut, oil and brown sugar aromas. Its rich palate was a ‘wow,’ a baby full of red fruits with a big monster finish. This was thick city and as impressive as any other wine on this night (97).

A 1967 Cantina Mascarello Barolo was a bit cloudy but still delicious. There were vitamins and black roses in its nose, with gamey rich flavors (95).

Then we came to the 1971 Giacosa Barolo Rocche Riserva. This was a wine that made time stop still. Bobby felt this wine was ‘everything that is right in the world.’ Apparently this was one of the greatest Italian wines Antonio had ever tasted, and I could see why. It was still so young, luring me in with its spice, cereal, earth and fire. Ok, there was wind, too J. It was so long, so sexy, so tasty…this was an elegant, vibrant and zippy wine. Bang pow zoom, I think this was the greatest Italian wine I have ever had, too (99).

The 1978 Giacosa Barolo Collina Rionda Riserva was a superb wine. This was classy with nice lemon, vim and vigor to its nose. There were solid earth flavors and great zip, spice rack and sparkle to its palate, which had great acidity (95).

A 1971 Marcarini Barolo Brunate was creamy and tasty with a nose full of caramel ice cream. There were vanilla flavors with that Italian kink (93).

A 1988 Giacomo Conterno Barolo Monfortino Riserva was tasty, creamy and special. That was all I wrote, and it was about that time (94).

Bad Boy pulled out a spectacular magnum of 1966 Dom Perignon, signaling the countdown for the evening. There were incredible wheat, toast and cream aromas in its perfect nose. This wine was hot, like a sexy hot, vibrant and long with a zippy finish (97M).

There were two wines to go, the first being a 1955 Giacomo Conterno Monfortino Riserva. Painted room was the first aroma that came to mind, opening up into old roses and old book. This was a tender wine, but it also had some brand new Lebron rubber sole goodness. Its palate was tender and smooth, hanging on to outstanding status but possibly not there much longer (95).

The last wine on this evening was another of the most spectacular Italian wines that I have ever had, even though it wasn’t from Piedmont. The 1971 Quintarelli Amarone Riserva was absolutely amazing, and about as intense a wine as I can remember. I am generally not a sweet wine drinker, but after 40 years in the bottle, this Amarone allowed me to bend my rules. Its aromas were almost addictive relative to the intensity and high it produced. That kink of gamey, pruny fruit was still there, but those were now overwhelmed by its acitidy and pepper. A touch of blood delighted the Vampire in all of us, and its palate was enormous, longer than 4th and 20 with the game on the line, but effortlessly good like the perfect pass for the win. This wine had me licking my lips hours later, and I felt privileged tasting it (99).

Not bad for Nebbiolo, not bad at all. Let’s see what Sangiovese has to say in a couple weeks!

In Vino Veritas,
JK

Monumental Mouton Weekend, Part II

I have to say that I love the private room at Per Se. Not the small one, the big one. If you want to do a great dinner for 20-50 people, there probably is none better. Not to detract from the 18 course extravaganzas, but there is something about 5-7 normal courses there that hits my sweet spot.

Wait a second, I’m not a food critic, and this weekend was about Mouton, and we picked up right where we left off the night before, except we were rocking to the Eighties. The 1984 Mouton Rothschild might not seem like an ‘I’m about to rock’ wine, but it was still soft, round and pleasant. It was a touch wheaty and weedy, showing pleasant purple and rock aromas. Its palate was smooth and easy, ‘not bad’ although there was a bit of cardboard flavors without being corked. Peter found it ‘sweet,’ and someone called it ‘a wet vintage’ (88).

Is it the Forest or the Trees

The 1983 Mouton Rothschild has always been a pet Mouton of mine, drinking wonderfully every time I have ever had it. This was no exception. The ’83 had a great nose with deep purple cassis and spice. Its palate was pleasing and long with nice nuts to its core of fruit. There was a good edge to its dry finish, and minerals, earth and tobacco were all invited to this relatively full-bodied wine. Dave admired its ‘more fruit.’ More is never enough J (93).

Bob and Tom were in the 1981 Mouton Rothschild camp. It had a nice nose with some water and chlorine to go with its chocolate, along with a nice kiss of mint. Its palate had an alcoholic kick to its finish but was leaner on its cherry fruit. Pleasant, balanced and high-toned, the 1981 still delivered pleasure (90).

1980 is another unheralded and forgotten year in Bordeaux, but the 1980 Mouton Rothschild was a pleasant surprise. There were lots of cedar, spice, mineral and coffee aromas in the nose, with a touch of dry grass and nice fruit. Its palate was round with nice green hues and decent depth. This wine was still solid, although probably not a vintage to drink by yourself over the course of an evening (90).

All About the Centerfold

The 1979 Mouton Rothschild had a rich and buttery nose with coffee aromas. Its palate showed the darker side of Mouton, with nice chocolate flavors. There was presence to its palate without weight, like a good ballerina. It had a full body and the longest finish of the flight, evoking ‘warmth’ from the crowd (92).

The 1978 Mouton Rothschild was another pleasant Mouton with a nice nose and more fruit than I expected. A hint of wood accompanied great charcoal and spice in this kicker of a nose. It seemed almost more Margaux than Mouton, and someone observed, ‘light body but full flavor concentration’ (90).

Technicolor Times

The 1975 Mouton Rothschild had a wafery nose that was gravelly with some carob qualities. There was nice balance yet loads of tannins to this back-sided baby. It got more chocolaty in the glass, complementing its smooth, dusty flavors (92).

I have always found 1971 to be a good, under the radar vintage in Bordeaux, and the 1971 Mouton Rothschild fit into that theory. It had a very minty nose with the first sign of that old, signatutre eucalyptus. There were cigar and ash qualities as well. Its palate was more plummy with nice body and a pleasant, round finish (90).

Keep On Keeping On

For some reason, I never finished my note for the 1970 Mouton Rothschild. I started with ‘deep, blacker fruit, long…’ but the note just stopped, as if it disappeared. Perhaps it was the corked 1966 Mouton Rothschild that followed (DQ),or perhaps the anticipation of the 1945 that was coming.

The third flight began with the legendary 1945 Mouton Rothschild. This particular bottle was reconditioned at the Chateau in 1977. There was a lot of instant cooing and purring, and someone quickly hailed it as both ‘the most beautiful woman in the world and a weightlifter on steroids.’ I found aromas of coffee, red spice, tea, mint, red cherry and honey in its complex nose. Its palate was round and tender, yet full-bodied. It continued to put on weight in the glass as it aired. Ed found ‘cola and five spice,’ while Bob noted its ‘Asian spices.’ Cedar came out more and more, and ‘Grandma’s old parlor rug’ came from Ed again, I believe. Peter noted, ‘dry flowers.’ Ed gave it 99 points, but I settled on (97).The wine was spectacular, but I have had other bottles of this wine hit higher notes. Just the facts, ma’am.

Monumental Indeed

Consecutive vintages of Mouton were unfortunately both (DQ)’d, both 1946 and 1947.

The 1948 Mouton Rothschild had that woody and weedy 1948 style, Left Bank that is. ‘Roasted with pure juniper’ came from the crowd along with ‘forest.’ Ice cream flavors went with its cedar box ones, and its elegant style made its earth and green qualities coalesce. ‘Concentrated celery’ and ‘celery root’ were also noted in this good Mouton (91).

The 1949 Mouton Rothcschild was again stunning, matching the bottle I had nearly three months prior. It was quite fresh, full of red fruits. This was a now, not an hour from now wine. It was really elegant, tender and feminine, quite pretty with its red fruits. Delicate and special, the ’49 had a touch of animal in a young herd kind of way (95).

Before There Was Color

I can’t remember the last time I had a Bordeaux, or a wine, from 1951, and the 1951 Mouton Rothschild didn’t give me much reason to investigate the vintage further. It was soft and simple, otherwise known as water city lol. If Jesus turned wine into water, it would probably taste like this (83).

The 1953 Mouton Rothschild had a gorgeous nose with beautiful fruit and nice tea and aromas. It was tender, smooth and satiny, a true mature lover’s wine. Ed found ‘roses’ and Alex ‘iron.’ While it didn’t have the weight of some of the others, it was lovely and oh so beautiful (95).

The next vintage has long been a personal favorite, that being the 1955 Mouton Rothschild. This bottle was a bit mature with a touch of oxidation to its tobacco road nose. It was soft and shut down on the palate with nice carob and caramel flavors, and it should have been better (94A).

The 1959 Mouton Rothschild hit the highest note of the weekend so far, ‘awesome’ as it was put. It had a great nose that was so deep and black with its young fruit. There were so many layers and complexity, garden and coffee being two examples. This was the fullest, biggest and blackest of them all, still delicate but all about the boom. This was the clock striking midnight and Cinderella coming home all in one (98).

The shadow of the ’59 ran deep; otherwise, the 1961 Mouton Rothschild would have stood out even more like the champ that it was. It was also black in its fruit, possessing cedar and cobwebs. It was the best balanced of its flight, full-bodied and beautiful. One had to work at it more, but the ’61 revealed classic cedar, cassis and tobacco in subtle yet extraordinary ways (96).

Birds of a Feather

The 1962 Mouton Rothschild was simple and didn’t belong in this flight, although I swear I had an impressive bottle of this in the past year. Perhaps, that is the company you keep theory (88).

We descended from the peak of that last flight to one of the peaks of the weekend, the 1982 Mouton Rothschild. Tom hailed it as ‘one of my favorite wines ever,’ and I saw the 1959 resurrected here. Balanced aromas of chocolate folded into intense depth in the mouth, with a chocolaty and creamy intensity to match. Its full finish came across youthfully, with lots of length and spice along with a touch of peanut. This was an all-star amongst all the major leaguers (98).

The 1985 Mouton Rothschild had green bean and honeyed fruit but was a bit weedy overall. Tom noted, ‘sweet pea’ and Ed ‘cucumber. It was solid and got better, with its green becoming more than tolerable (93).

The 1986 Mouton Rothschild has long been considered one of the all-time great Moutons, and while I have had a couple that have been worthy of that reputation, the majority show more like the one we had at this lunch. It was shy and tight with black fruit and even tighter leather aromas. Its palate was the same, bordering on square with a mineral highway of a finish. Diamonds galore sparkled, but ‘where is it going to go?’ asked one guest. Bryan found it ‘lacking the succulence of Mouton’ (95+).

Rockin to the 80’s

The 1989 Mouton Rothschild was a bit of a sleeper, showing lots of coffee aromas and flavors before its big finish. Its hard tannins gave a rustic and briary impression (93).

Green has always been the first word to come to mind when it comes to the 1990 Mouton Rothschild, and this was no exception. It wasn’t a bad wine, and it was more balanced than the 1989, as well as fleshier. Bryan found it ‘fresh and succulent but less complex’ than the ’89. Many preferred the open nature of the 1990 (90).

The last flight was more curiosity than kitty, starting with the 1987 Mouton Rothschild. This was a hay is for horses wine, with some weeds. It was a bit funky like a good chicken with flesh and good yeast flavors (89).

The 1988 Mouton Rothschild had nice t ‘n a and felt tight. It was white smoky with a dry, wheaty finish (89).

The last four wines only got a couple of comments out of me each at this point, so I will put them all in this last paragraph. The 1991 Mouton Rothschild was yeasty and unpleasant, a bit tutti frutti at this point (82).The 1992 Mouton Rothschild got no comment (83).The 1993 Mouton Rothschild was solid, a very good wine and clearly a head above the rest of these shoulders (92).Lastly, the 1994 Mouton Rothschild was tannic and dry (90).

Looks are Sometimes Better

It was a spectacular retrospective of one of the great properties in the wine world. Who’s next?

The Happy Recap

In Vino Veritas,
JK

  • Sign Up
Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.
×

Cart

Sign up for Acker exclusive offers, access to amazing wine events & world-class wine content!



    Please note there will be a credit card usage fee of two percent (2%) on the total auction purchase price up to the credit card payment limit of USD$15,000, HKD$150,000, or SGD$20,000 for live auctions, and on the total amount charged on internet auctions (except where prohibited by applicable law).